Press Release -23/10/2026- EU Court of Justice SmartFlats Ruling

PRESS RELEASE – 23/10/2026

 

EU Court of Justice SmartFlats Ruling will Affect Irish Government Regulation of STR

The Irish Self-Catering Federation (ISCF) welcomes today’s landmark judgment by the Court of Justice of the European Union in the Smartflats case (C-813/24), which reinforces important safeguards against unjustified restrictions on short-term lets.

The Court confirms that planning restrictions affecting short-term letting must comply with the EU Services Directive. Protecting housing is a legitimate objective, but authorities must demonstrate that restrictions are necessary, proportionate and that less restrictive alternatives would not achieve the same result.

 

Crucially, the judgment establishes that: –

• Restrictions – must be justified by evidence, including consideration of the actual impact of short-term letting on housing

availability and rents.

• Blanket restrictions – require careful scrutiny, including whether measures are

appropriately targeted at areas experiencing housing pressure.

• Less restrictive alternatives – must be considered before imposing prior authorisation requirements.

• Primary homes – deserve particular protection: housing objectives cannot justify the planning-authorisation requirement examined by the Court for temporary or partial letting of an operator’s primary residence.

• Challenge Restrictions – Both authorisation schemes and their individual conditions can be challenged where they fail to comply with EU law.

 

A clear warning for the Irish Government.

The judgment raises serious questions about Ireland’s proposed National Planning Statement. Based on the EU ruling, a population threshold is not evidence that short-term letting causes housing shortages. The Government must explain why restrictions are necessary in the areas concerned and whether less restrictive alternatives could achieve its housing objectives.

Ireland cannot solve its housing crisis by simply declaring small tourism businesses part of the problem. The Government must demonstrate, with evidence, that restricting short-term letting will actually help. A town’s population is not a housing-impact assessment.

“The ISCF calls on the Irish Government to review its proposed restrictions in light of the judgment, ensure proportionate treatment of different types of operators and protect established, legitimate tourism businesses” said Máire ní Mhurchú CEO of the Irish Self-Catering Federation.

Noelle Casey, the newly elected Chairperson of the ISCF runs a small dairy farm in Kerry with her husband. They diversified into self-catering to secure the survival of their family farm. Noelle said ‘Protecting housing is essential. But housing policy must be based on evidence, not assumptions — and must respect EU law. Most self-catering owners and those working in the holiday lets industry are women and the rural family income must be protected.”

Eoghan o Mara Walsh stated “We welcome the European Court of Justice Ruling on Smart Flats. We call on the Irish Government to introduce the Register for STR Bill, to give clear detail in other exact number of holiday lets. This sector is the 2nd largest provider of beds in Ireland, and essential to the tourism economy. The register should be set up now with and the planning conditions to follow consultation with the tourism sector to ensure that there is the right balance of short term rentals in urban areas as well as rural areas”.

European Court of Justice Smartflats Ruling 22/10/2026

ENDS

BRussels
Smartflats ECJ ruling says city cannot close down STR
Brussels City
The City of Brussels has pop. of 1,255,834 in 2026

 

About the Irish Self Catering Federation

The Irish Self-Catering Federation (ISCF) is the national representative and lobbying body for owners of self-catering properties in Ireland. Established in 1998, ISCF advocates on behalf of its members to promote and develop the interests of the self-catering sector across the country.

The ISCF has called for a Register for STR since 2017. Recognised by Fáilte Ireland, local andcentral government, and key tourism stakeholders, the ISCF works to ensure that self-catering accommodation providers have a unified voice in policy discussions and industry developments.

The federation represents a diverse range of property owners, from individual holiday home operators to larger agencies and groups. In addition to national advocacy, the ISCF is amember of the European Holiday Homes Association (EHHA), engaging in discussions and policy development at the European level to support the self-catering industry.

ISCF Conference takes place at Killashee Hotel on 23rd November 2026.

For media enquiries:

Contact the ISCF office, which co-ordinates all interview requests.

Office:- info@ISCF.ie      Phone: 086 – 178 5654   Join ISCF Now

Brussels
Brussels City Opera House

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *